Reference Checks – Part 2: Legalities and Effectiveness

Jun 20, 2018

In Part 1 we addressed the problems with reference checks, what to cover when doing them and the methods that could be used. This article, Part 2, focusses on the legalities and effectiveness of reference checking.
Section 14 of the Constitution – the Right to Privacy in the Bill of Rights – has relevance to both employers and employment agencies, when it comes to reference checking.
Because of this section, employers and employment agents are advised to obtain written permission before taking a reference from a current or previous employer. Employers would be well advised to verify, before accepting a curriculum vitae, that the recruitment officer or consultant has permission from the applicant, to release their confidential information to the employer or client.
Can employer be held liable?
Employers may refuse to give reference checks, provided they comply with Section 42 of the Basic Conditions of Employment Act.  This requires that employers issue a certificate of service, stating the name of the employer and employee, position held, dates of employment and salary earned, upon termination of the contract.  Should a previous employer refuse to give a reference he cannot be held legally responsible for any financial loss suffered by the new employer as a result of his refusal to give a reference. The law does not regard it the duty of the previous employer to protect the interest of the new employer.
Should the previous employer however, agrees to give a reference, he/she could be held liable for financial loss suffered as a result if withholding information likely to have had a material influence on whether the candidate would have been offered the position or not.  Say, for example, the previous employer is aware that the candidate had been treated for alcohol abuse and continued drinking after undergoing treatment.  The previous employer would be well advised to inform a prospective employer who is considering the applicant for a position requiring driving a heavy-duty vehicle on public roads.
Bad reference
The referee is entitled to give negative comment on the candidate.  It must, however, be true and relative to job performance in the position the candidate is being considered for.  Disclosing that the candidate being considered for a position as production manager, had an affair with a married member of staff, is not material to job performance.
It is sound business practice to do references and to be prepared to give references.  Employers who refuse to do so, cannot expect others to oblige them when they feel the need to obtain a reference check.  In certain instances, giving an objective reference check assists with the career development of an ex-employee, since it may provide information as to how to effectively manage the candidate.

Disclaimer: LabourMan exclusively provides services to employers.

The content does not constitute legal advice, are not intended to be a substitute for legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. Kindly contact us on or 021 556 1075 to speak to one of our consultants.


Wallace Albertyn

Wallace Albertyn is a Senior Associate and Legal Advisor at LabourMan Consultants.

Recent LabourTalk Articles

Dismissal of Prolonged Cases by the CCMA

Dismissal of Prolonged Cases by the CCMA

Introduction The case of South African Airways(SOC) Limited (in Business Rescue) and Others v National Union of Metalworkers of South Africa obo Members and Others (JA32/2020)...

Digital Evidence v Artificial Evidence

Digital Evidence v Artificial Evidence

With the proliferation of Artificial Intelligence (AI), it has never been easier to manipulate messages, videos or graphics. Therefore, the integrity of digital evidence in the...

LabourTalk Newsletters

Subscribe and receive labour related information

Follow us



© 2024 ~ All Rights Reserved  |  Privacy Policy